the lawyer writer

sometimes legal                     sometimes literary                     sometimes not

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

Adapt This

I am pleased to report that I did indeed see The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy this weekend, and that I thought it was quite good. Now, before all my fellow Hitchhikers beat me with things the movie missed or got wrong--and there were quite a few--allow me to say this: the movie got the spirit of the book right. This standard is in accordance with the principle thesis of my, er, thesis in graduate school, entitled "Fancy Dress: A Comparison of Period Piece Adaptations in Modern American Film." Before I be accused of trying to encourage readership of the aforementioned paper, let me reassure you that only one copy of the thesis exists, and it is resting comfortably in a dusty file cabinet waaaaay in the depths of the NYU Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. I would, of course, be happy to offer anyone a digital copy of the thesis, but, alas, it does not exist. Or rather, it does exist, on floppy, only I typed it on an outdated Mac computer using a program known as Clarisworks (a/k/a "Too Cheap For Windows"). This has encrypted it in computer hieroglyphics, and no known Rosetta Stone exists.

Back to the thesis's thesis. An adaptation cannot work if it intends to mimic everything in the book, down to the letter. Witness, for example, Sin City, which was adapted quite slavishly, and with the involvement of the comic book's author. Even the visuals were preordained. Now, I liked Sin City, but this was mostly because My Beloved Clive was in it. (Take a moment now to ponder Clive's rugged masculinity. Mmmmm. Clive). And the visuals. The story had its moments, but the narrative was bogged down by the filmmakers refusal to take chances.

The Hitchhiker movie is doubly cursed, as I realize through conversation with my friend--oh, let's call him "O"--who could not help but compare it to the v. successful British television series made of the book. I did point out to him that, in a television series, there is simply more time to fill in all the details and the blanks. In a film, things have to be sketched quickly. Think of an artist painting a brick wall. The amateur draws and shapes every brick in the wall, while the artist can paint the same wall with a few, well-placed brushstrokes. V. Zen, no? This is the goal of a film adaptation--not to mimic the book, which is impossible given the differences in the mediums (media? Discuss.) But instead, the goal should be to capture the spirit that the book itself was trying to convey.

I think the Hitchhiker movie does that quite well. This is 45% due to the casting of Martin Freeman as Arthur Dent. "O" noted that they had been working on the movie for decades, and it only got made through a convergence of bizarre fates: 1) Douglas Adams' death (a notorious perfectionist, he held the script up for years) and 2)Men in Black (proving that yes, people do want to see funny sci-fi movies with loads of special effects). To that list of chancey fates meeting, I would add 3) the birth and acting career arc of Martin Freeman, especially after The Office. (Question: why do I now find him sexy? Discuss).

So that's that. Now I have a quiz. A man in Japan claims to have invented a device which can translate the gurgling, babbling and general yapping of babies. (read here)Perhaps he thought of this gadget out of thin air, but I'm betting that the idea came to him while watching a) this television show as b) this character invented the same device.

Discuss.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Conair Cordless Dual Jet Bath Spa Shelf Stereo Systems
Shelf Stereo Systems
Conair Dual Jet Bath Spa provides home hydrotherapy to relieve arthritis, back and neck related pain and other conditions.

Think Finnish Sauna. Turkish Bath. European Spa. Mineral spas in England (in the aptly named town of Bath) and in Belgium (in a town named Spa!) attracted huge followings among the wealthy in Victorian and Regency times, and spas often even sold their water to drink. \"Taking the cure\" or \"taking the waters\" was considered medicinal and restorative. Some spas, built at hot springs, invited people to bathe and bask in the naturally warm pools. ... Shelf Stereo Systems

3:57 AM  
Blogger Greg said...

http://2relico.comwindows and windows Ideas for Home Construction projects. If you own a home and need to work on windows then al I want to say is Yea.... I wood love to let you in on a secret about home repairs... People ask me all the time about windows and they want to know simple ways to solve ther problems ...well I have the answers and If you go to http://2relico.com windows and go through the site you will find what you are looking for... what can I say butt get going ...

7:16 PM  
Blogger James Baker said...

I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you, Blogger, a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
If you have a moment, please visit my site:
wholesale computer accessories
It covers wholesale computer accessories related contents.
I send you warm regards and wish you continued success.

9:01 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home